Anurag Viswanath: Clouds of history |
|
Anurag Viswanath / |
|
|
|
Apart from the border dispute, |
|
Prime Minister Manmohan Singh’s maiden visit to |
|
Clichés aside, the visit was symbolic — issues such as the border dispute will fester in the background. The PM’s visit to |
|
The visit marked a sustained effort to institutionalise high-level visits and sustain the momentum of dialogue, which received a boost after former Prime Minister Atal Behari Vajpayee’s visit in 2003. The 2003 visit had concluded on a high note of the Principles for Relations and Comprehensive Cooperation, which marked |
|
The bilateral visit comes after the conclusion of the first Memorandum of Understanding (MoU) on defence cooperation between |
|
The visit took place in the backdrop of growing trade between the two. Sino-Indian trade which was $2.1 billion in 2000 has grown dramatically. It touched a high of $35 billion in 2007, up 54 per cent compared to 2006, making China India’s second largest trading partner. The target of $40 billion by 2010 set out in 2006 will be realised earlier. |
|
On this visit, the target is to be further pushed to $60 billion a year. Border trade between |
|
This visit will also take forward the recommendations of the Joint Study Group (Feasibility Study) on the Regional Trading Arrangement (RTA) and measures to facilitate the same. While there has been progress on bilateral trade, India’s growing trade deficit, estimated at $9 billion in 2007, as well as the composition of the trade of low-value primary goods (such as iron ore) is worrisome. |
|
The visit comes on the heels of new developments in the border region. Border negotiations continue to be tricky and remain under wraps. During the 11th round of talks between the Special Representatives, both sides agreed to form a Joint Working Group on the framework to resolve the issue. |
|
The dispute in the Western Sector (WS, that is, Aksai Chin) and Eastern Sector (ES, Tawang) remains intractable with 14 areas under dispute (eight in the WS and six in the ES). There is no dispute in the Middle Sector. The dispute in the Western Sector has become complicated with the transfer of |
|
|
|
|
|
There are allegations that tunnels built ostensibly for the railway may be used as missile bases. There are also unconfirmed reports that |
|
While the PM’s visit is a step forward, it is necessary, in the words of a famous sinologist, to see “ |
|
Given the nature of the above developments, rabble-rousing about the “China threat” provides no solutions; the Chinese have not prevented India from setting its house in order, such as developing relations with peripheral states or upgrading infrastructure in border areas. Both vacillate between the promise of genuine friendship and the inextricable cloud of history. It is necessary to close the “knowledge gap” between the two. Geo-strategic compulsions and globalisation have underlined that there are no permanent friends or enemies. |
|
And last but not the least, the visit entails lessons for |
|
What is admirable is |